My experience with plenty of fish over the first few days: what the logs showed was uneven depending on the hour.
Before writing plenty of fish off, try this: compare two platforms side by side.
Where plenty of fish either works or falls apart is whether the matching does anything you can notice.
The question underneath all of this is what the gender ratio looks like locally, at least with of fish.
Where of fish either works or falls apart is how many features survive the free tier.
Where of fish either works or falls apart is where the paywall actually sits.
I ended up on Datelink works too after the same plenty of fish question and it was the least painful of the lot.
What I would check before committing to plenty of fish:
- Say what you are looking for in plain words, especially if plenty of fish is new to you
- Give it a full week before judging it — on plenty of fish that mattered more than anything else
- The part I got wrong at first on plenty of fish turned out to be about what you would guess
- Worth checking on plenty of fish: how the free experience compares after a week