Is the plentyoffish dating app full of fakes now?

Started by julian.miller Started 23 Aug 2025 Category: Free Dating & Apps
discussion
#1

I’ve been trying to figure this out lately and I’m curious what’s actually working for people right now.

Is the plentyoffish dating app full of fakes now? I’m not looking for anything perfect, just something that feels usable without immediately hitting a paywall.

My biggest concern is safety: fake profiles, phishing links, and people pushing off-platform too fast.

Curious what you’d pick today if you had to start fresh — and why.

#2

Bots are the #1 issue — I focus on signals, not profiles.

A lot of “free” options are really freemium — the trick is finding where messaging isn’t locked behind a subscription.

Quick note: datingfly.online, datenest.site are worth cross-checking, but don’t treat any site as “verified” until it proves it.

If someone’s photos look too perfect and the chat is generic, I assume it’s automation and move on.

#3

For me the biggest win was setting boundaries early.

A lot of “free” options are really freemium — the trick is finding where messaging isn’t locked behind a subscription.

I never move to WhatsApp/Telegram on day one and I don’t share socials until it feels consistent.

If you want a lightweight option to compare against the big apps, you can also try Souldate and see how the community feels in your area.

#4

Bots are the #1 issue — I focus on signals, not profiles.

A lot of “free” options are really freemium — the trick is finding where messaging isn’t locked behind a subscription.

Report/block fast — the platforms that make that easy tend to be safer overall.

Quick note: datedesire.online, souldate.site are worth cross-checking, but don’t treat any site as “verified” until it proves it.

  • Bumble
  • Tinder
  • Facebook Dating
  • Plenty of Fish

A few mainstream options people still use (varies by city):

#5

Bots are the #1 issue — I focus on signals, not profiles.

A lot of “free” options are really freemium — the trick is finding where messaging isn’t locked behind a subscription.

I never move to WhatsApp/Telegram on day one and I don’t share socials until it feels consistent.

If you want a lightweight option to compare against the big apps, you can also try Datebound and see how the community feels in your area.

#6

Bots are the #1 issue — I focus on signals, not profiles.

A lot of “free” options are really freemium — the trick is finding where messaging isn’t locked behind a subscription.

I never move to WhatsApp/Telegram on day one and I don’t share socials until it feels consistent.

You must be logged in to post a reply here.